|
Reviews
The Sword in Anglo-Saxon England from
the 5th – 7th
century
Matthew Harffy
The Sword in Anglo-Saxon England, edited by Paul
Mortimer and Matt Bunker, is an
astounding achievement and a wonderful
addition to the
corpus on the subject. It is both
scholarly in its depth and approach and
at the same time accessible to the more
casual reader with an interest in early
Anglo-Saxon England, or swords in
general. It covers just about everything
you could think of about swords from
this period, from how they were used,
their place in the military culture,
their symbolism, how they were fashioned
and decorated, in-depth analyses of the
distribution of archaeological finds,
the different forging processes, the
ideology of swords and several case
studies of reconstructions of famous
historical swords, such as the Sutton
Hoo sword from mound 1 and the Bamburgh
Blade.
This is a hefty tome, weighing in at 450
pages [a bit over 1kg]. The
contributions are varied and for anyone
with even a vague interest in the
subject matter there will be some
chapters that will make compelling
reading. There are several highlights in
the book, but for me the detailed
descriptions of the pattern-welding
process and the step-by-step accounts of
forging replicas of pattern-welded
swords, with numerous enlightening
colour photographs, really stand out and
elevate this above other works by adding
in-depth practical knowledge from expert
blade smiths.
If you wish
to know more about swords, particularly
those from the early Anglo-Saxon period,
this encyclopaedic book is a must-buy.
The Sword in Anglo-Saxon England from
the 5th – 7th
century
Andy Ternay
As a
connoisseur of the European sword, a
bladesmith, a collector, a founder and
an administrator of the Facebook page
Ancient European Swords and a proud
owner of more books on swords than I
care to count, I have been awaiting this
book with great interest. Author and
editor Paul Mortimer did me the honor of
allowing me to view his text portions of
the book in advance, and this taste of
the material created a great deal of
anticipation on my part. Now that I have
in my hands the final text with
photographs, I’m pleased to report that
my wait has been richly rewarded. This
book is comprehensive, filled with
detail, and yet easily readable,
coherent and clear – in short, this book
is a treasure.
If one goes by the title alone, it would
seem that the topic is very narrow,
tailored only to a tiny audience
interested in the martial culture of
Anglo-Saxon England from January 1,
401AD to December 31, 699AD. The title,
while representing the central focus of
the book, is misleadingly confining.
Anyone with an interest in the Early
Middle Ages, regardless of specific
discipline (literature, sociology,
archeology, mythology, women’s studies,
military history, reenactment, material
culture studies, metallurgy and more)
will find this book relevant and
informative. Blacksmiths, bladesmiths,
leatherworkers, textile workers, and
jewelry makers with an interest in the
history of their respective crafts will
discover insights inside this book.
What differentiates this book from
others is its scope. Most sword books
take a specific approach to the sword
and rarely stray from that – an example
being Ian Pierce’s Swords of the Viking
Age. In that text, one is presented with
a catalog of historical swords, a brief
discussion of archeological typologies,
an informative section on
pattern-welding and the book concludes.
Contrast this with Paul Mortimer and
Matt Bunker’s presentation: a survey of
the previous publications on their
topic, discussion of the martial culture
of Anglo-Saxons, how the iron and steel
was made, charcoal production and
smelting, detailed discussion of pattern
welding and patterns found, the role of
the blacksmith in society in Northern
Europe, a survey of sword finds, how the
sword was clothed (guard, pommel, rings,
pyramids, stones, jewelry,
ornamentation, scabbard construction,
scabbard lining, scabbard covering), how
the sword was worn, the literature and
vocabulary of the sword, and runes and
inlay on a sword blade. A complete
survey of the sword from start to finish
– yet our authors/editors/contributors
are not done.
With contributions from expert
bladesmiths Vince Evans
&
Jesus Hernandez,
&
blacksmith Lee
Sauder, we are gifted with specific,
detailed case studies on the
reproduction of historical blades such
as the Sutton Hoo Mound 1 blade, the
Vehmaa and the Bamburgh swords, as well
as alternative techniques for sword
construction. Next, with the help of
Matt Easton, a long time instructor and
even longer time student of Historical
European Martial Arts, they explore how
the sword was used in combat, the grip,
and the combination of sword and shield.
This is followed by a look at the
archeological evidence for sword
inflicted trauma.
The book ends
by exploring the
meaning and life of swords in their
contemporary society, the burial of the
sword, and the relationships of women to
swords. These explorations of the
cultural interactions with the sword are
a welcome addition in any discussion of
the sword – it was not an object apart
from the culture; it was an intrinsic
part of the culture of Northern Europe,
and without the inclusion of this
material one is left to speculate why
these weapons are so important as
contrasted with any other implement of
the society.
As a final bonus, on author/editor Paul
Mortimer’s Academia.edu site, one can
download no less than 13 additional
appendices.
Finally, this book includes dozens of
high quality, color photographs to
illustrate the concepts. The usual
charts, diagrams and tables are also
provided where appropriate to guide the
reader in understanding the data
presented.
In short,
this is the exploration of the sword
that I have long been waiting for.
Buy it!
BACK
TO
BOOK
|
|